This post is one of contrasts. If you're taking part in Woolly Wormhead's Mystery Hat KAL, and you want to avoid spoilers, then do come back and read this post another day. There is a spoiler picture later on. You've been warned!
The first Hat that I want to tell you about is actually a bit of a sad tale... Back in October 2010 (thank you Ravelry for helping me keep track of these details!!), I knitted Community Gardens by Melissa LaBarre, using some lovely Crystal Palace Merino 5 Solid. It was part of my slightly bonkers Green Hat Phase, and I knocked the pattern out in just one day. I loved the Hat and I loved the yarn. Then my sister in law saw the Hat and she loved it too, so it became her Christmas present.

I looked forward to knitting another Hat in this yarn for me - after all, the shade is the exact match of my Namaste handbag, so it was surely meant to be? Fast-forward 2 years, and I'm bitten by the Hat bug (yes, you're to blame Woolly!!). I've finished the first installment of the Mystery Hat KAL, so I decide to cast on for a new Hat. This Merino 5 Solid will be perfect, as it's worsted weight (a heavy DK for UK types), and so it will knit up really quickly. I might even knock out another Hat in it before the next instalment of the KAL arrives on Friday... Or at least, that's what I was hoping...

I decided against knitting Community Gardens again. Not because I don't like the design - I do! But just because it's always nice to do something new. So I went over to Ravelry and did a search for Worsted weight Hats for which I already have the pattern in my library. There were quite a lot of options! But the winner was KoolHaas by Jared Flood (one of my favourite designers). I have always liked this design - the way that the cables merge into the head is SO appealling.
I cast on in front of Strictly Come Dancing on Saturday evening, and set off. I hit my first stumbling block a few rows in, when I found a section of yarn where one of the 2ply strands that the yarn is made from had broken. Since there are seven 2ply strands, I didn't worry about it too much. I carried on knitting and sewed the broken ends into the fabric. About 3 rounds later the same thing happened. And then there was a section with three strands broken. And I got a fair way into the cable section, all the time telling myself that it was OK, and I could just weave the ends in and it would be fine.

And then there were more. I got disheartened, and decided that really this wasn't going to be any good, when I came to an area with all but 2 of the strands broken. I admitted defeat and have ditched the yarn. I'm really sad, as I'm fairly sure that this must have happened while the yarn was in my care. It was fine when I knitted with it 2 years ago, but it really isn't fine now.
My first panic was that it was moth damage. But there were no areas where the yarn was entirely eaten through, and the broken areas weren't lined up in the ball in any way, so that seems unlikely. This ball had previously been knitted into a swatch, so maybe something happened at that point. Or perhaps the ball got scratched against something in my stash. Whatever it was, the yarn was too damaged to knit with. So with great regret I pulled out the half knitted Hat and have ditched the yarn. I will need to find some other worsted weight yarn to knit a KoolHaas though as I was enjoying it SO much!
In happier Hat news, I have completed the first section of my Mystery Hat KAL. Look away now if you don't want a spoiler...

The band is complete, and I've been looking in my button stash for a suitable button, but nothing quite works. I think that I will probably make a button with any leftover yarn. The book I'm working on at the moment has a lovely tutorial for Wheelhouse Buttons (or Yorkshire Buttons), so I might have to give that a test. In the interests of trying it out you understand...
I'm using UK Alpaca DK which is a BFL/alpaca blend and is a delight to use. I've not blocked the band yet, but I have a feeling that it will just be even more glorious once that's done.